Host Andrew G jokingly said James’ entry into the top four was a Steven Bradbury moment, referring to the Australian speed skating gold medallist who triumphed by, what some call, default.

“James, Steven Bradbury’s got nothing on you. You get to sing again.”

The 18-year-old was notably shaken when performing his first song, Daughters by John Mayer.

“James and Toby had become very firm friends, and I think James was sorry to see him go. I think he admired him for his decision,” said James’ grandfather, Ian Johnston.

Moulton’s exit from the show came as a shock to all the contestants.

“I have realised at this stage that I do not want a career in music and these four people do,” Moulton said

“They each have an enthusiasm and drive that I cannot match and I must step aside so they have the best chance to prosper as young Australian artists.”

Mr Johnston was impressed by the admirable decision but was disappointed by the show overall.

“Frankly I thought Sunday was one of the weakest shows put on yet. I thought the visiting American “superstars” were hopeless – theirs was the worst performance of the night. They didn’t perform as well as the amateurs.”

The Rainbow Flat resident was flabbergasted by the judges, who he said, contracted their opinions with each contestant.

Ian and his wife Margery, regularly call James on Sunday night after the show but couldn’t reach him this week, instead speaking to his father.

“He said James still remains very philosophical about things, and knows that if he goes on for another week will be very lucky.”